| Champion | Won at | Opponent | Reign |
| Mason Quinn | Warfare at Waverly | Silas Young | Oct. 19th, 2007-Present |
| Silas Young | Mid-American Wrestling | Dysfunction | May 5th, 2007-Oct. 19th 2007 |
| Dysfunction | MAW/ICW Beauty and the Butcher | Dinn T. Moore | Feb. 17, 2007-May 5th, 2007 |
| Dinn T. Moore | NWA WI in Cecil | Adrian Serrano | Feb. 25th, 2006-Feb. 17th, 2007 |
| Adrian Serrano | Titletown Takeover 7 | Eric Priest | Nov. 13th, 2004-Feb. 26th, 2006 |
| Eric Priest | Valentine Vendetta | Horace the Pyschopath | -Feb. 14th, 2004-Nov. 13th, 2004 |
| Horace the Pychopath | Green Bay, WI | Adrian Lynch & Dino Bambino | May 16th 2003-Feb. 14th, 2004 |
| Adrian Lynch | Mole Lake, WI | Travis Lee | Jun. 2nd, 2002-May 16th, 2003 |
| Champions | Won at | Opponent | Reign |
| Vacant | Warfare at Waverly | Dysfunction & Arya Daivari | Oct. 19th, 2007-Present |
| Dysfunction & Arya Daivari (Esteban Molina) | Mid-American Wrestling | Esteban Molina & Ricky Thomas | Mar 9th, 2007-Present |
| Esteban Molina & Ricky Thomas | NWA WI: Theresa, WI | Jack Berzerker & Tommy Courageous | Jun. 3rd, 2006-Mar. 3rd 2007 |
| Jack Berzerker & Tommy Courageous | Burnin' Down the House | Spanish Stew | Dec. 3rd, 2005-Jun. 3rd, 2007 |
| Spanish Stew | Titletown Takeover 7 | Brandon Blaze & Steve Stone | Nov. 13th, 2004-Dec. 3rd, 2006 |
| Brandon Blaze & Steve Stone | Kick Off Karnage 04, Part 1 | "Delicious" Danny Scott | Aug 28th, 2004-Nov. 13th, 2004 |
| XXXplicit Content | Battlegroung 04 | Spanish Stew | May 7th, 2004-Aug 28th 2004 |
| Re-Gex | Mole Lake, WI | Malice & Venom and Mike Mercury & Romeo Valentino | Jun. 2nd, 2002-Jan. 1st, 2004 |
| Champions | Won at | Opponent | Reign |
| "Simply Amazing" Justin Dredd | Beat the Heat 07 | "Cadillac" Nick Colucci | Jul. 14th, 2007-Present |
| "Cadillac" Nick Colucci | Seasons Beatings | Arya Daivari, T.C. Washington, and Joe Envy | Dec 9th, 2006 - Jul. 14th 2007 |
| Dysfunction | Late Knight Stand | Diego Corleone | Apr. 22, 2006-Dec. 9th 2006 |
| Diego Corleone | NWA WI: in Cecil | Esteban Molina | Feb.25, 2005-Apr. 22, 2006 |
| Esteban Molina | Winter Warfare 2006 | Ruff Ryder Rashaan & Diego Corleone | Jan. 28th ,2006-Feb. 25th, 2006 |
| Ruff Ryder Rashaan | Burning Down the House | Justin Dredd | Dec. 3rd, 2005-Jan. 28th, 2006 |
| Justin Dredd | Roughin' It | Shortstack | Jul. 9th, 2005-Dec. 3rd, 2005 |
| Shortstack | Green Bay, WI | 4 Way Match | Apr. 1st, 2005-Jul. 9th, 2005 |
